How to make sure a new document management system is up to the challenge

E

By Eva Mrazikova

Global Head of Product Marketing

Key takeaways:

  • This blog looks at four challenges CPA firms face when choosing and adopting document management software – value, sharing, policies and risk.
  • Ensuring value: A document management system (DMS) only earns its keep if your team uses it. Plain-English AI search, automated filing, and version control make it easier to use than the workarounds staff fall back on.
  • Proper document sharing: Replace email with a secure client portal connected to your DMS and add an Outlook add-in so documents that still arrive by email get filed too.
  • Matching software to policies: No single retention period fits every firm. Set rules by service type, statute of limitations, and regulation. Have legal counsel review them and let your DMS enforce them on schedule, with legal holds where needed.
  • Governance and risk: Define roles, assign clients to teams, and ensure people only see the documents they should.

One of the main reasons you buy document management software isto save time looking for files. Time, after all, is something a CPA firm needs to be billing, not spending searching for documents. Unfortunately, things don’t always work out as planned.

There’s a danger you invest in a solution and then still end up hunting for documents because the solution is not up to the job. In response, staff still save documents on desktops, clients email attachments, and retention is tracked using a headache-inducing spreadsheet.

In the end, questions continue to linger about which are the latest versions of documents, and who can access them.

So, how do you make sure that document management software is up to the task? This blog provides answers to four of the big challenges you face when picking the right solution. Meet these challenges and you will be well on your way to success:

  • Challenge #1: Ensuring value –does document management software save enough time to be worth it?
  • Challenge #2: Proper document sharing – what software can replace email when it comes to asking clients for documents securely?
  • Challenge #3: Matching software to policies – what retention policy should a CPA firm be following for client records, and how can a document management system help?
  • Challenge #4: Governance and risk – how do I set up a DMS so staff only see assigned clients’ files?

Challenge #1: Ensuring value – does document management software save enough time to be worth it?

It can, as long as your team actually uses it. You can only drive technological change in your CPA firm if the software is truly worth your time and has the functionality you need. But if core features like search are clumsy or filing means clicking through endless folders, people drift back to what they know best – desktops and email inboxes. As a result, the firm pays for a system that holds only half its documents.

How to ensure a new document management system is worth it:

  • Ensure its search function matches how people ask for documents in real life. You want full-text search with optical character recognition (OCR) that covers scanned PDFs, tax documents, and workpapers. AI search in the most modern solutions allows staff to type or say what they need in plain English.
  • Automate the filing process. The act of filing can be time-consuming, but there are ways to remove this workload. Rules that route incoming documents by template, folder path and year take manual filing off your team's plate.
  • Create documents in bulk. Generate the same document from a firm template for dozens of clients at once, with each copy named and filed to the right folder, and preview the run before it starts.
  • Use your own tags to mark up documents. How you label your documents makes a huge difference. You need to be able to do so using tags that are built around how your firm works to keep classification clear and consistent across teams.
  • Control versions. Few things are more painful than trying to work out if you have the latest version of a sensitive document in front of you. Check-out and version history stop two people overwriting the same file. Editing Office files inside the document management system removes the download, edit, and re-upload routine.
  • Reduce risk for partners. Legal holds can stop files being deleted during a dispute or an IRS examination, so firm owners know the record is intact.
  • Build in security and retention. Single sign-on (SSO), two-factor authentication (2FA), retention rules, and audit trails should run without manual effort.

IRIS Document Management pairs AI search with full-text search and OCR, files documents automatically with rules-based routing, and keeps everyone on the right version with check-out, versioning, and in-app Office editing. Find out more about IRIS Document Management

Challenge #2: Secure document sharing - what software replaces email when asking clients for documents?

In short, you need a secure client portal that is connected to your document management system. This is a protected conduit for information being shared between you and your clients. Email might feel easy, but attachments end up in individual inboxes, outside your retention rules and access controls, and clients lose track of what they've sent.

How to replace email with a secure portal:

  • Have a portal that is easy for everyone to use from the first login. Clients need to see what's outstanding, what's changed, and what they need to do, with a guided start the first time they log in.
  • Make sure the portal shows status and urgency. When clients can see whether each file is pending, accepted, or rejected, and who approved it, you get fewer "did you get my file?" emails.
  • Ensure the portal comes with an activity feed, so your team and your clients can see what happened and when.
  • Use AI where it helps clients. A plain-language summary can help clients understand their part in a process.
  • Brand it. Your logo and colors remind clients who they're working with. Pick a portal that allows this.
  • Get an Outlook add-in for when the portal isn’t used. Some documents will always arrive by email. Staff should be able to file emails and attachments to the right client folder without leaving their inbox.

IRIS Document Management includes a brand-able, 2FA-protected portal where clients can see the status of everything they submit, while its Outlook add-in lets staff file emails to the right client without leaving their mailbox. Find out more about IRIS Document Management

Challenge #3: Matching software to policies – what retention policy should a CPA firm be following for client records, and how can a document management system help?

There's no single answer to this question. The right periods depend on your services, your location, and your clients, so design your own policy and have legal counsel review it. The common challenge is a policy that exists on paper but isn't enforced, or no policy at all, so everything is kept forever.

Keeping everything has a cost. The Journal of Accountancy warns against tipping from caution into "records hoarding". The FTC Safeguards Rule also requires firms to securely dispose of customer information no later than two years after it was last used to serve the customer, unless the firm needs it for legitimate business purposes or the law requires it to be kept.

Keep what helps you serve the client, respond to regulators, or defend a professional liability claim: think about how you store engagement letters, fee and billing records, supporting workpapers, and the reports you issue.

Areas you might want to consider when setting and enforcing retention rules… and picking a document management system to handle them:

  • Make sure you can set document management system rules by service type. Match tax files to taxing authority audit periods. The IRS generally has three years after filing to assess tax, six years if unreported income exceeds 25% of the gross income shown, and seven years for bad debt or worthless securities claims. Employment tax records need at least four years.
  • Many firms default to seven years, the longest standard IRS period, so make sure your system can keep things safe for this kind of timeframe. Store documents where a server failure or other serious incident won't affect them. Good cloud systems keep data backed up, so any outage won’t affect you.
  • Make sure your software can help you work with statutes of limitations. Professional liability limits vary by state, and the discovery rule can extend them. Make sure your document management system’s retention rules are able to adapt accordingly.
  • Ensure your software can help you look after regulated clients. Clients subject to government regulation or funding may need longer periods. Check that any system you shortlist can handle longer periods for these clients.
  • Pick document management software that can enforce your retention policies without endless manual intervention. Apply retention periods to folder templates so expired files are removed on schedule, with legal holds to override deletion when needed. If you have the right system in place, this should make the process much more error- and stress-free.
  • File emails to client records, so they follow the firm's retention rules. Ideally this should be done quickly. An Outlook add-in would be a strong solution for most CPA firms.

IRIS Document Management builds retention management and legal holds into the system, and its Outlook add-in brings emails under the same rules as every other client file. Find out more about IRIS Document Management

Challenge #4: Governance and risk – how do I set up a DMS so staff only see assigned clients' files?

You need a document management system that makes the client the unit of access. File every document under a client record, give each person a role that defines what they can do, and assign clients to teams rather than individuals. Then link those assignments to your practice management system so access follows the work.

This matters for compliance as well as confidentiality. The FTC Safeguards Rule requires tax and accounting firms to limit access to customer information to authorized users who need it and employ multi-factor authentication. IRS Publication 4557 sets out similar expectations for tax professionals.

A good document management solution enables you to do the following:

  • File by client. Documents saved to desktops, personal drives, or inboxes fall outside your controls, so email needs filing too.
  • Define a few roles. Partner, manager, staff, and admin, each with set rights to view, edit, delete, and share.
  • Assign clients to teams. When someone joins or moves teams, their access changes with them, with no folder-by-folder setup.
  • Flag restricted clients. Staff members' own returns or high-profile clients should be limited to named people.
  • Secure sign-in. Use single sign-on (SSO), two-factor authentication (2FA), and conditional access, such as limiting logins to firm-managed devices.
  • Review and offboard. Check the audit trail regularly and turn off access the day someone leaves.

Folder permissions on a shared drive can get you partway there. But they drift over time, leave email uncovered, and record little about who opened what.

IRIS Document Management combines role-based access control with SSO, 2FA, conditional access, and audit trails, so people only see what they should, and you have a record of who opened what. Find out more about IRIS Document Management

How IRIS Document Management adds value, protects documents, and reduces risk

IRIS Document Management is a cloud-native document management system (DMS) built for CPA firms. Use it on its own or connect it to IRIS Firm Management.

  • Find documents in plain English. AI search works alongside full-text search and OCR.
  • File with less effort. Auto Filing rules route documents by template, folder path and year. AI tagging uses your firm's own tag library.
  • Work on the right version. Check-out, versioning, and Office editing inside the DMS, plus an Outlook add-in for filing emails.
  • Give clients one place to collaborate. A branded portal with 2FA shows clients the status of what they submit and what you share.
  • Stay in control. Role-based access control, SSO, conditional access, audit trails, retention management, and legal holds support defensible document handling.

Note: IRIS blogs should not be considered advice or legal confirmation when it comes to subjects such as document retention. Consult a legal expert if in doubt about your obligations.

Eva Mrazikova

Global Head of Product Marketing

Eva Mrazikova is Global Head of Product Marketing at IRIS, where she leads go-to-market strategy, competitive positioning and product marketing across IRIS’ Accountancy and HCM portfolios in the UK and US.

With more than 20 years’ experience spanning product marketing leadership, commercial strategy and technology transformation, Eva brings a rare blend of strategic vision and hands-on execution to complex, multi-product businesses.

A recognised product marketing leader and qualified accountant, she has spent her career at the forefront of digital transformation, helping organisations navigate the shift from legacy platforms to cloud-based, AI-enabled solutions while driving measurable commercial outcomes through market-led strategy.